Barbagia: The Shepherds' Sardinia
by Joseph Harris

The land Rome named and never took.
The name is an insult
The Romans took Sardinia from Carthage in 238 BC and held it for nearly seven hundred years. They held the ports, the grain plains and the mines. They did not hold the mountains in the middle. The people up there came down to raid the farms and went back up where no legion cared to follow, and Rome, which had a name for everyone it could not manage, called the place Barbaria: the land of the barbarians. The word wore down over the centuries into Barbagia, and the people who live there kept it. It is the only region in this book named by its enemy.
In the Sicily chapter we said that the rulers of an island are a layer laid over the people, and that what is left when the layer wears off is what always was, plus the food each ruler left behind. Barbagia is the other half of that thought. Here the layer never went on. Carthage, Rome, Byzantium, Pisa, Genoa, four centuries of Spain and then the House of Savoy all ruled Sardinia from the coast, and every one of them stopped at the same line of granite. What you eat in Barbagia is not what survived the rulers. It is what was never interrupted.
Sheep, bread and cheese
Sardinia has about two sheep for every person, and Barbagia is where the arithmetic comes from. The whole kitchen is built for a man who leaves the village with his flock in the fall and does not come home until spring. His bread is pane carasau, baked twice until it is as thin and dry as paper so it will keep for months in a saddlebag. His cheese is Fiore Sardo, a raw sheep's milk pecorino lightly smoked over the fire of the hut where it was made. His meat is whatever can be cooked with a fire and a stick. Nothing in this kitchen needs a court, a port or a spice merchant, and nothing in it ever had one.
The one extravagance is a pasta, and it is the rarest in the world. Su filindeu, the threads of God, is semolina dough pulled by hand and doubled eight times into two hundred and fifty-six strands finer than hair, laid across a tray in three crossed layers and dried into a sheet like lace. Only a handful of women in and around Nuoro can make it. It is broken into mutton broth with fresh sheep's cheese and given to the pilgrims who walk overnight from Nuoro to the sanctuary of San Francesco at Lula. Nobody can put that on a Tuesday menu, and we did not try. Our first course is the same bowl in plain clothes: shepherd's broth with potato, sweet onion, fine broken pasta and pecorino.
The foil: the Emerald Coast
Two hours north of Nuoro is the Costa Smeralda. In the early 1960s the Aga Khan and a group of investors bought a stretch of empty shoreline from shepherds who thought seaside land was worthless, because nothing grew there and the sheep would not eat it, and built the most expensive resort in the Mediterranean on it. That is the Sardinia the world knows: yachts, white villas and a harbor full of people who will never go inland. It is the latest ruler to arrive by sea and stop at the mountains. The island the visitors photograph is a coast. The island that feeds them is behind it.
Who came from there
Grazia Deledda was born in Nuoro in 1871, left school after the fourth grade because that was all the schooling the town gave a girl, and wrote novels about shepherds, priests, bandits and family honor in the villages around her. She was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature for 1926, the second woman ever to receive it, one hundred years ago this year. She did for Barbagia what the Romans never managed: she got inside it, and she did it by telling the truth about its people.
The mountain keeps its own music as well. Canto a tenore is four men standing in a tight circle, one singing the words and three answering in low throat voices said to be the sounds of the sheep, the cow and the wind. And it keeps its old men. The villages of the Barbagia and the neighboring Ogliastra hold one of the highest concentrations of men past one hundred anywhere on earth. The explanations offered are steep hills walked every day, sheep's milk, beans, bread, a glass of red wine and a village that never retires anyone. It is close to what this book calls the Mediterranean diet, practiced by people who never heard the phrase.
The Menu
Primo: Shepherd's Broth (Brodo del Pastore) with a Fennel and Orange Salad (Insalata di Finocchi e Arance)
Winter fennel and winter oranges with black olives, oil and salt; the orange juice is the dressing.
Secondo: Sardinian Gnocchetti with Sausage Ragù (Malloreddus al Ragù di Salsiccia).
An honest note: malloreddus come from the Campidano, the plain to the south, and the mountain adopted them the way every Sardinian table did. The classic sauce carries saffron. Saffron ran in our first Sardinia dinner in May, so this one leans on toasted fennel seed instead.
Terzo: Slow-Roasted Pork Shoulder (Maiale Arrosto alla Barbaricina) over braised cabbage.
The feast dish of the island is porceddu, a suckling pig turned on a spit over myrtle and juniper wood for most of a day. This is the same idea brought indoors: a shoulder with bay, rosemary and garlic, left in a low oven overnight until it gives up.
Dolce, for the book only: Aranzada Nuorese.
Orange peel cut into fine threads, simmered in honey and tossed with toasted almonds, the wedding sweet of Nuoro.
The wines
There is no Sardinian bottle on our list this season, so the flight is built from relatives. Vermentino is Sardinia's own white grape; ours is the Doga delle Clavule from the Tuscan coast, which faces the island across the water. The Costa Pinot Noir from Comptche takes the pasta. The red for the pork is Nero d'Avola, Messer del Fauno, from the other great island, standing in for Cannonau, the mountain red the old men of Barbagia drink every day. The flight of three is $20.
$29 per person · Children 12 and under $12 · Served family style
Chi mangia bene vive bene


